Some ground rules:
- Only use the appropriate pinglists for your sales threads (there are different categories for certain G1 and G2+ not-cats!). If you aren't sure, you can always use the general sales pinglist, or you can ask me! On a similar note, make sure to check that you've added the right cats to your sales post so it doesn't look like you're misusing the pinglist.
- Do NOT harass anyone who has a not-cat that you want, and DO NOT try to intentionally lowball anyone, especially if they aren't aware of special IDs.
- Make sure to pay attention to the special requests on the pinglist before you ping anyone.
- Don't use the pinglist on replies to this thread for your sales or ICs, and share Not-Cats elsewhere. It's more helpful for potential buyers if you have the type of special ID in the title, and keeps the forums nice and neat. This is the 'Guides' section, after all, not the 'Cat Sales & Trades' or 'Cat & Village Share' section.
- Be nice, and don't criticise someone for asking questions, even if they were already answered in the thread.
The spreadsheet is admittedly a little complex. There are lots of different categories and terms that I use, so don't be afraid to ask anything if it confuses you! If the day comes that thousands of people are on the pinglist, I will try my hand at utilising a sheet that is connected to a google form, so that sellers can copy pings from a single cell, but that requires more complex knowledge of google sheets than I actually have right now.
How should I navigate the spreadsheet?
The main pinglist is separated into categories, sub-categories and purchase method. There is also an area for buyers to ask for wishlist-fulfilling not-cats in the 'Unique Request' sections. General is a miscellaneous page, but all the other categories and sub-categories have definitions in this thread.
Buyers:
The main pinglist is seperated into categories, sub-categories and purchase method. Once you've picked what you are interested in, add an @ and your username to the right column.
It's worth noting that 'IC' is shorthand for 'interest check', where people search for buyers and ask for advice on pricing. Normally ICs are for the seller to decide whether they should host an auction or flatsale, since a successful auction needs at least two interested buyers. If you want to be pinged for sales only, add yourself to the respective flatsale and auction pinglists.
There is also a 'Unique Requests' section for each major category.
- Example 1: If you're looking for a milestone ID albino, use the section on the Milestones page.
- Example 2: Only interested in Gardenhome G1 palindromes? Ask for a ping in the U.R. on the palindrome page!
- Example 3: LOVE the number 8? Use the UR pinglist on the general page to ask for special IDs with the number 8 in them
If you have multiple special ID not-cats on your wishlist, please use a different cell for each individual cat in the UR pinglist, as it makes it clearer to sellers what you are looking for.
Sellers:
Look at the guidlines on the SINCC thread to see what kind of special ID you have. Ask a question on the thread or PM @minim (#2682) if you aren't sure.
Next, are you holding an interest check, flatsale or auction? For interest checks, use the 'All Sales/ICs' pinglist for your respective ID categories, and for auctions or flatsales use both the 'All Sales/ICs' and Auction OR Flatsale pinglists. If you're hosting something unusual like a raffle, I'd recommend doing an interest check and pinging the 'All Sales/ICs' pinglist for it and collating a pinglist from people who want to join.
Always ping the general pinglist as well as the specific pinglist!
Check the 'Unique Request' pinglists. I recommend looking at the specific ID category ones for your not-cat first, and then at general.
Pricing Help?
The special ID collecting community is currently so small that special IDs aren't really worth any significant amount unless it is a major milestone ID (the 150k ID with hidden heart mantle was recently auctioned for +20kn). Special IDs have a bit of rarity, but next to no demand. This means you are (currently) best getting pricing guidance elsewhere for a 'base price' and then adding a bit extra.
I am currently looking for people who have already bought special IDs. If you've ever bought a not-cat with a notable ID, I have some questions that I'd love to ask you in order to improve future price estimations for other special ID cats:
1. What was the ID number? (I will categorise the number myself)
2. What other factor(s) can you think of that also affected the value?
3. Did you buy the not-cat from an auction, CRB flatsale, or private negotiation?
4. What was the price/What did you trade for it?
5. Was it a Nestor/Gardenhome G1? Or was it G2/G3+?
6. Is it okay for me to share all these details with PCE players via the forum?
I will probably make another spreadsheet for this purchase data, but this and the pinglist has already taken up a whole week of my time so I'm going to take a break for now and just pop them in a third post.