I've been getting more and more into petsites because most of them allow me to pace myself and decide how much time I want to put into them.

I'm currently on Flightrising (main), goatlings, Lorwolf, and chickensmoothie (but I'm sure there are some I'm forgetting about).

Flight Rising!

Do Lioden and Wolvden count as virtual pet sites? (Though I go through stages where I don’t visit them) If not, I also use Flight Rising, which is where I’m more consistently active depending on how I’m feeling, I also play Lorwolf sometimes(which is where I found this site). And I also play Pokéfarm Q

Maybe a little biased because I'm a mod there but 4dopt is a small pet site where users make all the species and items with tons of customisation options! It's really really fun and everyone is really nice, I've played a lot of pet sites but 4dopt is the only one I've played this consistently since I joined not long after it opened a bit over 3 years ago

I saw Sylestia mentioned a couple of times in the thread. I'd personally advise against playing it, since some of the assets are AI generated. Example 1, example 2, example 3, admin confirmation here.

Other than PCE, the site I'm most active on is Flight Rising.

I also check BeastKeeper now and then. It's got a neat genetics system, and it's pretty chill since your pets only need to eat on days that you log in. Unfortunately, the playerbase is super tiny, which makes buying things a bit of a pain, but I think it's possible to get anything you need from exploring, including premium items with a low chance, which is nice. Getting pets from the pound is definitely something you should do if you play, since you can get pets bred to have great genes and stat boosts

i saw a couple people mention subeta already, but that's mostly where i am. even if i dont post much, i'm usually there just doing quests and achievements.
as a kid though i'm pretty sure i was on almost every virtual pet site. my main go to used to be kenopets which was later renamed to anatheria. i used to most rp there and chat.

First I found PCE through my FR (Flight Rising) elemntal flight's discord. Managed to sign it the same day I saw it talked about but now I do think I had heard of the site before as I was already following their tumblr, I think.

As mentioned above I do play FR but I am bit bored of grinding on there for hibden tasks.. You will find me there with the same username.

I do play neopets but you will not find me there with the same username and it's a completely different one. There are daily quest now you can get morphing potion and even paint brushes. And I think some retired items which are technically unretired.

I used to play Cromimi but I think this site doesn't exist anymore and I don't think I used christinewho there.

edit: I forgot to mention Neopets is giving us a new site plot this year. Another game I forgot I to mention was sylestia but I do not like that game as my stakes are full of critters and I have 0 space now feel too much Pay to play.